How to Choose a No. 74 Mach3 Razor: Handle Options Explained

By TOBS | Luxury Grooming Products for Men | Taylor Old Bond Street | Published: 2026-11-03

Category: Buying Guides

Compare the No. 74 Mach3 Razor in imitation ivory and black handles. Learn which finish suits your routine, how Mach3 blades fit, and what to decide before buying.

Quick answer

Choose the No. 74 Mach3 Razor with the black handle if you want a low-key, easy-to-match finish for daily use. Choose the imitation ivory handle if you prefer a warmer, more traditional look that stands out on the shelf. Both take the same Gillette Mach3 blades, so the decision comes down to finish, not shave performance.

The handle is the only real difference

Both No. 74 Mach3 razors share the same Mach3 blade system and the same Jermyn Street-inspired design. The catalog lists different prices, but the shave itself is identical. That means you are choosing a finish, not a different level of closeness or comfort.

If you already own a Mach3 razor, you can keep using your existing blades with either handle. If you are switching from a disposable or another system, the blade cost and availability are the same for both.

When the black handle makes more sense

A black handle hides water spots and soap residue better between cleanings, which matters if your razor lives in a busy shared bathroom. It also pairs easily with dark countertops, black trim, and most modern travel kits.

The black handle is the lower-priced option in the current catalog, so it is the practical pick if you want the No. 74 design without paying for a decorative finish.

When imitation ivory is worth the extra

Imitation ivory gives the razor a warmer, more classic look that resembles traditional shaving tools without using animal ivory. It stands out against white or marble surfaces and looks more intentional as a gift or display piece.

The trade-off is visibility: light-colored handles show soap scum and hard-water marks more readily, so you may need to wipe the handle after each use to keep it looking sharp.

One limitation to know before you buy

The catalog does not list handle weight, length, or material beyond the finish description. If you prefer a heavy, weighted razor or need a specific grip length, you cannot confirm those details from the product page alone. In that case, treat the No. 74 as a style-led choice and check the physical specifications with the retailer before ordering.

Decision rules for choosing your No. 74 handle

If you want the lowest-maintenance finish: Pick the black handle. It hides soap film and water marks better between cleanings.
If the razor will sit on display or be given as a gift: Pick the imitation ivory handle. Its lighter tone reads as more traditional and stands out on a shelf.
If you are matching an existing shaving set: Choose the handle that matches your brush, bowl, or stand. Both razors use the same Mach3 blades, so the finish is the only visual variable.
If you need confirmed weight or length: Do not assume either handle is heavy or lightweight. The catalog does not list those specifications, so ask the retailer before ordering. Check the return policy in case the handle feels different from what you expected.

Product facts

No. 74 Mach3 Razor with Imitation Ivory Handle: Mach3 razor with an imitation ivory handle, named after the No. 74 Jermyn Street store. The light finish gives a traditional look, but it shows residue more easily than dark handles.
No. 74 Mach3 Razor with Imitation Ivory Handle
No. 74 Mach3 Razor with Black Handle: Mach3 razor with a black handle, named after the No. 74 Jermyn Street store. The dark finish is more forgiving in daily bathroom conditions and costs less in the current catalog.
No. 74 Mach3 Razor with Black Handle

Who should choose which

Best for

Shoppers who want a classic-looking Mach3 razor with a traditional finish
Gift buyers looking for a presentation-friendly razor
Men who already use Gillette Mach3 blades and want a more stylish handle

Not for

Shoppers who need a confirmed heavyweight or long-handle razor
Anyone looking for a double-edge safety razor rather than a cartridge system
Buyers who want a razor with a pivoting head and trimmer, which the catalog does not list for this model